Dutch Mill Rochester
Dutch Mill Logo

Dutch Mill

4.3879 reviews

Dutch Mill offers a cozy setting for food lovers. Located at 2901 Dewey Ave, this cafe and grill attracts locals with its inviting atmosphere. The spacious layout features a pool table, making it a perfect spot for casual gatherings and friendly games.

Visitors find comfort here, whether it's for a hearty lunch or an evening out. The restaurant serves a varied menu that highlights both American and German cuisine. Their delicious offerings appeal to a wide range of diners.

About

Nestled in Rochester, Dutch Mill has become a community staple. Since opening, it has developed a laid-back vibe that invites everyone. Regulars often drop by, creating a warm neighborhood feel.

In the past, the venue hosted notable events like the Libertarian Party meet and greet in 2018. Diners enjoy the ambiance while savoring delightful food. The mix of laughter and good conversations fills the air, making each visit memorable.

Get in Touch

2901 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616, United States

Opening Hours

    Where to Visit

    Get Directions

    Customer Reviews

    "Spacious bar and restaurant with pool table, clean bathroom and ample parking. There are a lottery machine, popcorner and gumballer. In the dining area are a low dais and projector for television. Back in 2018 the Monroe County Libertarian Party hosted Larry Sharpe here during his historic run for New York Governor."

    - Daniel D.

    "Katie is the best. The food is great. Chicken wings are awesome and if you go on Sunday get the fisherman's Bloody Mary."

    - christopher f.

    "The service great and the german potato salad awesome. It's a summer night and its very busy so I had a great time"

    - Jose F.

    "A good meal, at a good price in a good neighborhood bar. Good, but unremarkable. Had a late lunch on Saturday. There was about ten other people there, and most seemed to be well known regulars. The atmosphere is a local bar. A bit worn out, but clean with fresh air and some windows providing natural light in the front. Service was laid back, but reasonably prompt. The food came out quickly and was hot. There was no trouble getting the bartender's attention even though it was clear she was good friends with one group of customers. We started with a pretzel appetizer. The pretzels were excellent, but the mustard dipping sauce had a bit too much horseradish for our taste. My reuben was decent. My wife's chicken sandwich was was good, but a little hard to eat. The chicken breast kept falling out. The fries were excellent, golden and crispy. My mac salad was unremarkable."

    - Timothy C.

    "This place is a fun Hangout! It's nice in size there are pool tables dart boards full menu great food!! The bartender Kevin is awesome!! Drinks and food both very reasonably priced!! Owners are usually available if you need anything. They have a private room to throw parties and also do catering."

    - Megan M.

    "Excellent food & prices!! Our waitress, Katie, did an excellent job & had a great personality. I usually only tip 20%, but I gave her a tad more bcuz she was so awesome! My daughter had a cheeseburger, my son had boneless wings, & I had the chicken special. All three were delicious & such a great price!"

    - Aimee S.

    "This is probably one of the best local restaurants you can go to in the North Greece area. The food is always delicious plus the quality and portions you get for the money are crazy. The specials are always interesting and creative, the owner oversees food production a good portion of the time or he is taking part in preparing the food, and all the drinks are quiet reasonable in comparison to other bars in the area, they have half price drinks from 2-4pm, and fifty cent wings on Thursday, all day. My girlfriend and I are regulars at this point and we go here once or twice a week. I highly recommend everyone give this restaurant and bar a shot at some point. You might just find yourself becoming a regular, too."

    - Keith S.
    Write a Review

    Why Visit

    Visiting Dutch Mill is a must for anyone in the area. It offers a welcoming environment combined with an engaging atmosphere. The service is attentive, with staff who genuinely care about customers' experiences.

    On Sundays, you can't miss the Fisherman's Bloody Mary, renowned for its rich flavors. Enjoy table games like darts and pool while sipping a refreshing drink from their impressive selection. It's a great place to relax after a long day.

    Prices range from $10 to $20, making it affordable for all. Families love their wide range of options, from mouth-watering chicken wings to hearty sandwiches. Perfect for both casual diners and special celebrations, Dutch Mill fits every occasion.

    Most Liked Things

    Customers rave about the exceptional atmosphere and friendly staff. Katie, a favorite waitress, often receives praise for her excellent service. Many recommend trying the chicken wings and the freshly made pretzels. The inviting setup encourages guests to stay longer, enjoying food, drinks, and games.

    Most Disliked Things

    Some patrons mention the atmosphere feels slightly worn. A few found certain dishes underwhelming, noting that the mac salad could use improvement. Occasionally, it gets busy, which can lead to slower service during peak hours.

    Regulars sometimes feel that the menu lacks variety for adventurous eaters. However, classic comfort food remains a favorite for many, keeping the core diners satisfied.

    FAQ

    What makes Dutch Mill special?

    Dutch Mill stands out with its spacious layout, pool table, and fun atmosphere. The combination of good food and entertainment, including live music, creates a lively environment for everyone.

    What are some must-try dishes?

    Don't miss the chicken wings and the fisherman's Bloody Mary on Sundays. The German potato salad also receives rave reviews, making it a favorite among patrons.

    Is there parking available?

    Yes, Dutch Mill offers ample parking to accommodate guests, allowing for a stress-free dining experience.

    What is the average price range for meals?

    The average price for meals at Dutch Mill ranges from $10 to $20, making it an affordable option for both lunch and dinner.